CLUAS - Irish indie music webzine
CLUAS on Twitter

The CLUAS Archive: 1998 - 2011

Josh Ritter

A review of his album 'The Animal Years'

Josh Ritter 'Animal Years'Review Snapshot:
The Chris Rea of the "Other Voices" generation, adopted Irishman Ritter returns with more of the same word-heavy singer-songer seriousness. If you like dancing and you have T-Rex or Prince records in your collection, you won't need to be buying this.

The Cluas Verdict: 3 out of 10.

Full Review:
Josh Ritter's Irish success mirrors that of David Gray a decade earlier - an adopted acoustic artist tapping into the Irish folk/indie scene. The more cynical may recall an earlier visitor, Chris Rea, whose 80s rock blandness has its equivalent in Ritter's typically vague and rambling singer-songer unoriginality. Nonetheless, Ritter is successful in Ireland, so new album 'The Animal Years' can count on an eager fanbase.

Ritter's reference points stand out like runway lights - the gruff Biblical country-rock of Steve Earle ("Girl In The War"), Springsteen-esque desert landscapes ("Monster Ballads"), all splattered by Dylany vocals.

However, like so many of his peers, Ritter's weakness is that for lyrics he writes reams of poetry and then tries to cram them into flat unmelodic songs with no choruses or melodies or hooks. As a result, this is an unmemorable album in every sense of the word. The lyrics, one gets the impression, are more important than the music - all instruments subordinated to the poetry, all accompaniment unobtrusive and therefore bland.

"Monster Ballads" gives the game away. Straining under yet more redemption-in-the-desert imagery (including a laboured pun on the word 'station', as in 'radio-' and '-of the cross'), its tastefully-plinked piano could have come straight from a Norah Jones record.

So, let 'The Animal Years' and Ritter's success in Ireland be entered as evidence for the prosecution of the puritanical pretentiousness and creative sterility of the Irish music scene today.

Aidan Curran

(bullet) To buy a new or (very reasonably priced) 2nd hand copy of this album on Amazon just click here.
(bullet) Check out the thread this review sparked on the  CLUAS discussion board.