CLUAS - Irish indie music webzine
CLUAS on Twitter

The CLUAS Archive: 1998 - 2011

This review was first published on CLUAS in 2003
Other albums reviewed in 2003

Cat Power

Review of their album 'You Are Free'

Cat Power You are free"You are free", is the long awaited release of new material from Cat Power (better known as Chan Marshall). It has been a while coming and the question must be, has it been worth the wait? 30 seconds into the first track, I can say yes. Well sort of.

'I don't blame you' is the sound of a fragile Tori Amos but manages to keep to the 3 minute mark (something Tori unfortunately fails to adhere to time and time again). The thin, angular acoustic guitars that launch 'Free' reminds us what Marshall does best - makes the sublimely simple look complicated and layered. What's more her voice appears to have lost a bit of the rather irritating Riot Grrl snarl. The consequence is that the gentler vocals actually appear to pronounce the songs more than before.

Her trademark sound of lazy guitars mixed with violins and wandering vocals resurfaces on 'Good woman'. Her folk-tinged voice brings back memories of the legendary Jeff Buckley, she having the same beautiful frailty to her voice as the much-missed Buckley.

'Speak for me' is the sound of The White Stripes mixed with a certain British female artist - it always amazes me that Beth Orton is not compared to Chan Marshall in anything I have ever read. Anyone who doesn't see this link is clearly not paying attention. If you were to take the acoustic guitars from Orton's recent album "Daybreaker" and electrify them, you would get a mirror image of this CD.

The charming blues tinge in 'Baby doll' provides a lovely break from the otherwise trashy folk-pop nature of this album, but does becoming quite boring after a while. Closing with 'Evolution' featuring the dark, deep vocals of Eddie Veder, the album departs on quite a lonely note.

Although still emotionally charged, it appears Marshall's outlook on life has brightened since the troubled "What Would The Community Think" and "Moon Pix" albums and I am not sure if this adds or takes away from her. Lyrically quite poor, musically good but a little samey, this release does not quite match the brilliance of her earlier work. But don't write her off just yet.

Graham Smith

(bullet) To buy a copy of this album on Amazon just click here.
(bullet) Cat Power are signed to the Matador record label.