The CLUAS Archive: 1998 - 2011

Entries for December 2008

28
Marion Cotillard with her Oscar for Best ActressMon dieu, is it the end of the year already? Well, before we step into 2009, there remains one piece of outstanding business – we need to reveal our choice of the best French albums and songs of deux mille huit.
 
(But first: have you checked out the 2008 CLUAS readers’ poll and writers’ poll results?)
 
We’ve found loads of great French music during the last twelve months; we hope you’ve enjoyed it. Thanks to everyone who e-mailed and commented during the year - all your feedback, tips and suggestions have been greatly appreciated.
 
So, it’s time to start opening golden envelopes and handing out mantelpiece ornaments. Who’ll join the lovely Marion Cotillard (right) in winning a prestigious honour for France?
 
Albums: No instant classics this year (2006 is looking more than ever like French pop’s annus mirabilis) but plenty of fine long-players all the same. (Links are to the act’s MySpace page.)
 
'Don Lee Doo' by Kim1. Kim ‘Don Lee Doo’
Kim Stanislas Giani clearly adores ‘80s pop mavericks like Prince and Kate Bush, which can only be A Good Thing. His 17th album in 14 years (and he’s only 31) is infused with the spirit of ‘1999’ and ‘Hounds Of Love’ - eccentric but enthralling electro-pop. He also makes his own videos, and every track seems to have its own website or MySpace page. Let’s hope he doesn’t start taking it easy in 2009.
 
 
2. Barth ‘Cuchillo’
Another idiosyncratic Frenchman who’s chopped his name; John Lennon soundalike Barthelemy Corbelet here tempers his Beatles-y indie-jangle sound with a distinct Americana alt-country shuffle and a dash of Ennio Morricone. There’s some reggae thrown in too. As with Kim, half the pleasure of this album is wondering where it’ll turn next.
 
3. John & Jehn ‘John & Jehn’
A likeable mix of ramshackle acoustica and streetwise art-pop from a French couple living in London. Odd packaging: a double album format with a ‘John’ disc and a ‘Jehn’ disc – the only problem is that our copy had the tracks mixed up. Or was this deliberate? You’ll figure it out.
 
4. Underground Railroad ‘Sticks And Stones’
And here’s another French band exiled in London. This young trio were championed by the NME for their angular Sonic Youth-influenced alt-rock – slightly squally and occasionally abstract, but with several cracking singles.
 
5. M83 ‘Saturdays = Youth’
It’s fine stuff, although a whole album of misty synths and oblique mumbling isn’t for everyone. But Anthony Gonzalez (note to self: two ‘z’s) and friends won’t be going home empty-handed – see our ‘Songs’ list below.
 
6. Syd Matters ‘Ghost Days’
Jonathan Morali’s hushed singing style and quiet acoustic arrangements concealed some smart, witty songwriting that plays with the stereotype of self-pitying singer-songers. A record that rewards attentive listening.
 
7. Papier Tigre ‘The Beginning And End Of Now’
A throwback to the early-‘90s U.S. alt-rock sound of The Jesus Lizard and Rage Against The Machine, the debut record by this Nantes band was full of well-written songs delivered with focused energy. Visitors to Eire in 2008, they could do well in a festival slot next summer.
 
8. The Dø ‘A Mouthful’
Charming indie-pop with enough oddness and eccentricity to keep it fresh and interesting. That said, Olivia B. Merilahti’s voice has a certain nails-down-the-blackboard quality, so approach with caution. Imagine how fantastic this album would have been if she could sing!
 
9. Minitel Rose ‘The French Machine’
From Jean-Michel Jarre up to Air, no one does retro-futuristic electronica like the French. Here’s more of it – ‘80s nostalgia infused with 21st century attitude.
 
10. Tahiti 80 ‘Activity Center’
Pleasant, uncomplicated guitar-pop with a sweet, sincere white-boy-soul centre. They’re Big In Japan, we believe.
 
(We also liked: Herman Dune ‘Next Year In Zion’, Apple Jelly ‘Nanana Club’, Mareva Galanter ‘Happy Fiu’, Cocosuma ‘We’ll Drive Home Backwards’, Poney Express ‘Daisy Street’, Stanley Brinks 'Dank U')
 
NOT Album of the Year: Camille ‘Music Hole’
Wow. This one was a real stinker. Graceless egotism, hypocritical sneering at other singers, flimsy songs shored up by excessive vocal effects – a future university course on Disastrous Follow-Up Records would be sure to feature this terrible successor to our 2005 Best French Album. Quite simply, a huge disappointment.
 
Roll of honour ~ Albums
2008: Kim ‘Don Lee Doo’
2007: Dionysos ‘La Mécanique Du Coeur’
2006: Emily Loizeau ‘L’Autre Bout Du Monde’
2005: Camille ‘Le Fil’
 
Songs: Plenty of fine French tracks in 2008. However, unlike the album list, one song stood out as a clear winner, ever since we turned on the radio late one night last April and heard something magical pouring out… (Links are to the video for each track, all working and correct at time of writing.)
 
Dreamy synth-shoegazing, like a cross between My Bloody Valentine and Air. Much-abused music-review clichés like ‘ethereal’ and ‘atmospheric’ suddenly became fresh and essential for describing this song’s chorus, a swirl of keyboards as Anthony Gonzalez sings “Somebody lurks in the shadows/Somebody whispers”. Gorgeous stuff.
 
2. John & Jehn ‘20L07’
A couple singing about how they love each other. No, wait! It’s actually quite funny and charming and catchy! And they explain the chorus so that it all makes perfect sense. 
 
3. Underground Railroad ‘25’ 
Hints of The Cure spice up this twisting, beguiling slice of college alt-rock, featuring guitarist Marion on vocals.
 
Like a midfield genius dragging an ordinary team to victory, sometimes a great chorus is enough to make a memorable song. So it is with this cartoon-punk thrasher, when singer Geraldine answers her own question in a glorious pop technicolour hook. (Note: not Californian band The Dodos)
 
5. Martin Solveig ‘C’est La Vie’
Fancy that! Old chipmunk-face makes a single that’s not only non-irritating but actually a cracking bit of Jacko/Justin dancefloor pop. The album of the same name proved to be a dozen dodgy photocopies of this song, but that’s understandable.
 
6. Poney Express ‘Paris De Loin’
The sound of escaping into the deep heart of the French countryside, cycling through sleepy villages and picnicking on bread, wine, cheese and ham. All that, conjured up by breathy vocals, a pulsing bassline, skiffly drumming and strumming strings.
 
7. Sheryfa Luna ‘Il Avait Les Mots’
For all its popularity and chart success, French R n’B-flavoured pop produced little of enduring quality this year. The exception is this classy single that fused US soulfulness with cold French keyboards. The video is interesting: the plot development at 3 mins 50 secs was the singer’s actual condition at the time of filming.
 
8. Apple Jelly ‘Radio’
It’s the disco-pop cracker from the Alpine foothills that’ll have you going “You know, maybe I should pick up a Boney M compilation sometime!” Such is the terrifying power of this catchy floorfiller. (But get a Chic record instead.)
 
9. Tahiti 80 ‘All Around’
Simple, catchy indie-pop, so radio-friendly that if you hold it up close to your ear you can hear the traffic news.
 
10. Benjamin Diamond ‘This Is It’
Some slick, romantic nightclub-pop by a former UK chart-topper. We figure that this is what Sebastien Tellier was aiming for with his poor ‘Sexuality’ album. (No video, so you'll have to visit Mr Diamond's MySpace page.)
 
(We also liked: Kim ‘Radio Grady’, Emily Loizeau ‘Sister’, Quidam ‘Nos Souvenirs’, Melissa M ‘Cette Fois’, St Augustine ‘Icelandic’, Maya Barsony ‘La Pompe A Diesel', Herman Dune ‘Try To Think About Me’, Syd Matters ‘Everything Else’, Barth ‘Magic Wondermeal’, The Rodeo ‘I’m Rude’, The Dø ‘On My Shoulders’)
 
NOT Song of the Year: Noir Désir ‘Gagnants/Perdants’
You’re a famous rock star who wins early release from prison, having served only half of a controversially short sentence. A year later you bring out your comeback single. Surely you wouldn’t be so insensitive, stupid and out-of-touch as to sing a song that (without ANY hint of irony) criticises the privileged of society while identifying yourself (rich rock star released early from prison, remember) with the poor and oppressed! And apart from the moral hypocrisy of the act, it’s a turgid whine of a ballad. (There’s already a discussion thread here, should you have strong feelings on the matter.)
 
Roll of honour ~ Songs
2008: M83 ‘Kim & Jessie’
2007: Pravda ‘Body Addict’
2006: Vanessa and the O’s ‘Bagatelle’
2005: Camille ‘Ta Douleur’
 
So that’s the year in French music. Here’s our Best French Song of 2008, ‘Kim & Jessie’ by M83 – see you in deux mille neuf
 

 


More ...

[Read more...]

Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
27
So, you’ve seen the results of the annual CLUAS polls. You, our suave and brainy readers, gave Elbow their second major prize of the year by choosing Mercury-winner ‘The Seldom Seen Kid’ as your top album. We, the aloof and mysterious CLUAS writing caste, had the audacity to reverse your top two: silver for Elbow and gold to Bon Iver for the lovely ‘For Emma, Forever Ago’.
 
If you feel the need to talk about it (for instance, if you = Glasvegas fan), everyone’s waiting for you on this thread over at the CLUAS discussion board.
 
All that remains now is for this blog, the Latin Quarter of CLUAS, to dish out the goodies in our annual Best French Music list. First, though, it may be interesting to see how France’s music publications saw 2008. The French make lists too: let’s compare two of the most prominent to CLUAS’s.
 
Les InrocksLes Inrockuptibles is France’s top music and culture magazine. In their Top 50 Albums of 2008, first place went to MGMT’s ‘Oracular Spectacular’. (You may recall that a mere underground train ride away in London, the NME also picked MGMT as their album of the year.) And the rest of the top five: Fleet Foxes, Vampire Weekend, Santogold and (yikes!) The Last Shadow Puppets.
 
We note that Nicole Atkins’ marvellous 2007 album ‘Neptune City’, released only this year in Europe, made the lower reaches of the Les Inrocks list. Has anyone in Eire heard of this wonderful record?
 
Only nine of Les Inrocks’ Top 50 are French albums. (By comparison, with nine Irish records out of 40 the CLUAS readers' poll has a much healthier domestic representation.) At number nine is the highest home finisher, Sebastien Tellier’s ‘80s-synthpop mess, ‘Sexuality’. Camille’s horrendous ‘Music Hole’ finished 12th. One of the nine French albums is Justice’s live album, ‘A Cross The Universe’, which hardly counts as an album for the pruposes of polls. And no place at all for M83’s “Saturdays = Youth”, which finished 18th in the CLUAS readers’ poll.
 
An Irishman writing in English about French music: bizarre. By contrast, it’s not so strange to discover Sound Of Violence, the excellent French music webzine dedicated solely to UK and Irish alternative music.
 
Sound Of Violence has also published its Writers’ Top Ten of 2008. Only British albums, remember, so no MGMT, Vampire Weekend, Santogold, Bon Iver or Fleet Foxes. Of Her Majesty’s pop stars, CLUAS and Mercury laureates Elbow didn’t make the cut – nor did Glasvegas. (No Irish albums in there either.)
 
Foals, then, win SOV’s prize, ahead of The Kills, Portishead and (eek!) Noah And The Whale. Other big names in the top ten are Oasis and Bloc Party.
 
Even if you don’t speak French, it’s still interesting to have a look at the Les Inrocks and Sound Of Violence end-of-year lists. If anything, you’ll see that Paris pop tastes closely follow the London trends.

Here’s a British song about moving to the French capital, from an album that wasn’t in the SOV, Les Inrocks or CLUAS polls - from the self-titled debut by Friendly Fires, this is 'Paris':


More ...

[Read more...]

Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
26
So did you get over the Christmas okay? And did Mr Making-A-List-Checking-It-Twice bring you what you wanted?
 
'French Connections' by Martin JamesThis Christmas time, someone correctly figured out that the CLUAS Paris correspondent is quite ignorant about much of the music going on in his beat. Yes, we received a book about French electronica.
 
‘French Connections: From Discothèque To Discovery’ is the uninspired title of the work in question (right), written by Martin James. Published in 2003, it’s a history of French electronic music. We’ve just started reading it and no doubt we’ll be dipping into it on these pages during the coming months, if not years.
 
Two wonderful facts from James’ book: (1) The Village People were assembled by two Frenchmen, Henri Belolo and Jacques Morali, and the group’s original Indian chief was another Frenchie, Felipe Rose. (2) ‘D.I.S.C.O.’ by Ottowan (you know the song) was written by the father of Thomas Bangalter from Daft Punk. No wonder he never shows his face in public.
 
However, we have a major gripe: after just one chapter we lost count of the factual inaccuracies, bad style and spelling mistakes that shake the book’s credibility. From the very first paragraph: “Even enfant terrible of the film world Quentin Tarantino grabbed his 15 seconds of disco delight with the 1998 movie Boogie Nights.” Lazy, bloated writing; no internal punctuation; misused metaphors – and Boogie Nights was made by Paul Thomas Anderson, not Tarantino.
 
Furthermore, we learn that Britain’s first disco opened “in 1862” – truly ahead of its time, as Thomas Edison only invented the phonograph 15 years later. And a few pages later, in a book purporting to be a history of modern French music, the name of France’s biggest rock star is misspelled as ‘Jonny Halliday’. It’d be a brave writer who’d submit shoddy copy like that to the CLUAS gaffer.
 
Still, we’re sufficiently intrigued by James’ opening pitch; France invented disco. The word ‘discothèque’ is French, and the first discos – the first nightspots for dancing to recorded music and not a live act – opened in Paris as underground music clubs during the Nazi occupation. The modern disco, with its garish décor, restricted access and air of exotica, also originated in Paris with clubs like Whiskey-A-Go-Go and Chez Regine. (The latter, near the Champs-Elysées, is still open.)
 
As for claiming the disco sound for France, this book is not so convincing. It’s hard to pinpoint one record where Motown pop, funk basslines and Philly soul strings came together for the first time, although Van McCoy’s ‘Do The Hustle’ is generally credited with popularising what we now know as disco.
 
A night on the tiles: CerroneBut a Frenchman can claim to have invented disco’s distinctive four-on-the-floor beat. His name is Jean-Marc Cerrone, a Parisian drummer known just by his surname. On his 1976 album ‘Love In C Minor’, Cerrone (left) put his bass drum right to the front of the mix, kicking out a simple four/four beat. Et voilà: the classic disco rhythm track that anyone can dance to.
 
Apart from percussion, the rest of ‘Love In C Minor’ is what we would today consider cheesy disco: string swoops, synth riffs – and plenty of orgasmic female groaning. Cerrone was notorious for the machismo of his music and album art, with sleeves that feature him as a Casanova-type figure attended to by naked ladies who also appear in his videos. (This is the classic French sexism that persists in the Parisian visual media even today: naked women in ads and magazines are not there for softcore exploitation. Oh no – they’re au naturel.)
 
So, despite selling millions of records Cerrone has dated badly, both sonically and visually. His work sounds kitsch beside that of Giorgio Moroder or Nile Rodgers and Bernard Edwards. But he still has his fans: Goldfrapp named a song for him on her 2008 album ‘Seventh Tree’ and called her 2005 album 'Supernature' after Cerrone's 1978 million-selling album of the same name. And Bob Sinclar is the self-appointed heir of Cerrone, remixing the older man’s work and keeping it on the chic dancefloors of Paris and the Riviera.

Here’s Cerrone’s biggest hit – the title track from ‘Supernature’. You’ll see what we mean about the cheesy ‘70s sexism:


More ...

[Read more...]

Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
21

If Christmas comes, can the end of the year be far behind? Well, no - it'll be a week later, like it always is. And if there's one thing that music lovers associate with the end of the year, it's spending New Year's Eve at the same old local with the same old people and pretending you're having a gas time. Sorry, two things: that and... end-of-year polls! Yes we can!

The results of the CLUAS annual poll will be announced very shortly. Warning: the CLUAS electoral commissioner, fresh back from the ballot boxes of Zimbabwe, has ruthlessly stamped out all messing and multiple voting and what have you. He may have been distracted somewhat when he found Miss Zimbabwe waiting in his hotel room dressed only in 'Vote Mugabe' stickers, but he won't be fooled again.

Our own humble blog (as humble as a Kerryman living in Paris can ever hope to be) will also be having its annual Best French Music poll. Sometime after Christmas, in the last week of the year, we'll list our choice of the ten best French songs and albums of 2008.

Thanks to everyone who has mailed and commented so far to tell us what they liked and hated and went 'meh' to. Have a browse through our 2008 posts and feel free to mail us at the address on the right or leave a comment at any of our old posts.

Benjamin Diamond(We note that 'Saturdays = Youth' by M83, as well as being a front runner in our Ligue 1 domestic poll, is also in the Champions League international CLUAS poll. What are the chances of Anthony Gonzales doing the double?)

Here's a recent French single we like very much - 'This Is It' by Benjamin Diamond (left). Unbeknownst to you (or perhaps beknownst, if you're a pop trivia fiend), you've already been dancing to the sound of Diamond, real name Benjamin Cohen. He was the vocalist on 'Music Sounds Better With You' by Stardust, the UK-chart-topping collaboration with Thomas Bangalter of Daft Punk.

Diamond has just released 'Cruise Control', an album of slightly cheesy electro-ballads. Imagine David Guetta trying to seduce you; that's the general vibe. That said, 'This Is It' is a quality bit of slow-set pop.

There's no video for 'This Is It' yet, so you'll have to visit Benjamin Diamond's MySpace page to hear it. So that gives us a chance to revisit one of the rare French tunes to be a hit in the UK charts - the rather tasty 'Music Sounds Better With You' by Stardust:



More ...

[Read more...]

Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
20

Over the three years of this column-turned-blog, we've raved repeatedly about the wonderful Emily Loizeau, exhausted every superlative in singing her praises. We're about to do so again.

The best a man can get: Emily Loizeau and her beardy friend.If you've just joined us: mademoiselle Loizeau's gorgeous debut record, 'A L'Autre Bout Du Monde', was our pick as best French album of 2006. By turns achingly melancholic and blissfully optimistic, the album blended pop, folk and cabaret in much the same way as Duke Special, with whom she has recorded and performed live.

Now, appropriately in this season of angels announcing births of messiahs and so forth, we hear that Emily Loizeau's second album, 'Pays Sauvage', will be released on 2 February. So, already one reason to look forward to 2009. The album has been recorded with a plethora of French folk-popsters, including David Herman Dune (formerly of the family group that still bears his name), Olivia Ruiz and Moriarty.

The first single, 'Sister', is available for download from online French music-pushers like iTunes, FNAC and Virgin. Unlike the piano-led pop of her first record, this track is an acoustic folk-pop shuffle, complete with whistling and a brass section. And Loizeau croons breezily over it all, forgoing the cabaret dramatics of her earlier songs for something more laidback. All in all, it's rather charming and a good sign for the forthcoming album.

Being Anglo-French, Loizeau is bilingual and has recorded version of 'Sister' in English and en français. You can hear both on her MySpace page.

And check out the poster (above right) for her Paris shows next spring (ah, springtime in Paris!) that features a bearded lady. Brilliant. We heart Emily Loizeau. (She's the one without the beard.)

Here's a brief snippet from the studio, man, of the English version of 'Sister':


More ...

[Read more...]

Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
19

Prompted by French Letter, here are some of Short Cuts' favourite "newly discovered" Aussie bands.

[Read more...]

Posted in: Blogs, Short Cuts
Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
19

Ah, Christmas in Paris! Even for those more cynical than your blogger, it's something quite marvellous here. We strolled down the Champs-Elysées a few nights ago, shivering in the cold but our hearts warmed by all the lights along la plus belle avenue du monde (below right).

Champs-Elysées in Paris, lit up for ChristmasOver on the Boulevard Haussmann, the grands magasins (department stores) have their epic Christmas window displays, the best free show in town. As usual we inspected the windows of Galeries Lafayette and yes, our favourite was there: a toy stuffed animal bashing the bejaysus out of a drum kit.

You might have heard about the recent bomb scare at Printemps, the other big department store on the Boulevard Haussmann. Almost bizarrely, the bomb squad found the device - five sticks of dynamite. French police have pulled in Yosemite Sam for questioning.

One huge difference between Christmas in France and in the English-speaking world: the radio stations are not churning out wall-to-wall festive classics. "Ah," says you, "no doubt they play their native Christmassy hits!" Well, no.

Quite simply, there are no French Christmas pop songs. No Yuletide singalong hit by Johnny Hallyday or Serge Gainsbourg, no modern indie Christmas songs by Phoenix or M83. Rien de tout. The reason, we suspect, is that French acts take themselves far, far too seriously.

But this doesn't mean the French aren't open to influences from off foreign. One indie music radio show this week did a feature on English-language Christmas pop songs. Gobsmacked with wonder, they played snippets of obscure festive songs by The Beach Boys and The Ramones. And then, we swear, there was the following exchange between the two presenters:

Guy: Finally, we have a real treat - a Christmas song by... John Lennon!

Girl: No! You mean, with The Beatles or solo?

Guy: Solo. It's called 'Happy Xmas (War Is Over)'. In England they play this all the time at Christmas. Here it is...

And then they play the first verse, with the same air of awe and bemusement as if they were peering into a pharaoh's tomb. (Closing the tomb lest the curse get out, they cut the song before Yoko started singing.) So, France is a land without Christmas pop music - and without any versions of 'Hallejulah'. Imagine there's a heaven.

For most French people, one song is synonymous with Christmas - a dainty little ballad called 'Petit Papa Noel' dating from the 1940s. Here's the definitive version, sung by Tito Rossi. Joyeux Noel!


More ...

[Read more...]

Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
18

Venture capital is pouring nicely into China’s music scene. See Chinese ringtones specialists Hurray earlier this year spending US$3 million on a 61% stake in Taiwan's Seed Music Group Limited. But will those big deals stop, now that pension funds won’t be so easy to hand cash over to the VCs? The man who knows a lot about these things, Ed Peto runs events managers Red T Music and writes a fine blog, OutIndustry.

Heck, in researching this blog I've gotten bogged down in the other blogs out there on the China music scene. I like both http://www.music2dot0.com/ and China Music Radar. There are others out there too, mostly started by foreigners living in China. The best English-language blog written by a local Chinese fan - and likely the best of all the blogs on Chinese rock, Rock In China.

I've come to the conclusion that they're all snazzier looking than Beijing Beat but that many of them, especially the expat-authored blogs, seem to blur out after a few fantastic entries and then go silent for a few weeks, then a few months. I'll have to meet some of the folks behind these. More on the VC later: I'm meeting Modern Sky next week.


More ...

[Read more...]

Posted in: Blogs, Beijing Beat
Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
17

I’m in Dalian to

Queen Sea big shark, lovely pace with Where Are all the passengers until we suddenly move up a serious change of gear and tempo. My new favourite China sound is the The Guai, listened to at Yugong Yishan the other night. I’ve been looking for them online.

Black Cat Bone
More ...

[Read more...]

Posted in: Blogs, Beijing Beat
Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
16
I was wondering where the Glamorous Pharmacy CD release party was. Now I know: The band, famous in China for its its theatrical stage moves, played their new tunes for an audience of intimates at the Penghao Theatre is a badly needed café theatre on Dongmianhua Hutong, just off the Nanluoguxiang bar strip. A courtyard, roofed, adjacent to a comfortable café-restaurant, the Penghao was also a perfect venue for I heart Shakespeare, a selection of the Bard’s words peformed by expat and local amateur actors.
To avoid being knocked over by car or man since the Naluoguxiang area’s been invaded by retro shops and camera swaying tourists I don’t go down that way anymore: hwo this place changed in 2 years – which is probably why I didn’t see the theatre. All the state media attention in China tends to go to huge vanity projects like the egg shaped National Theatre near Tienanmen Square, designed by French architect Paul Andreu.
Nearly every city has one of these outsized but infrequently used cultural venues, or is copying one of the famous theatres of the world (knock-offs of the Sydney Opera House abound in China’s interior cities). Not a lot happens at these places as government cash tends to be reserved for state-run troupes the likes of which did the Olympic Games opening ceremony. These state-paid performers are rarely fountains of fresh new theatrical ideas. Which is all the more reason why the country needs the like of the Penghao.

More ...

[Read more...]

Posted in: Blogs, Beijing Beat
Actions: E-mail | Permalink |
Page 1 of 3First   Previous   [1]  2  3  Next   Last   

Search Articles

Nuggets from our archive

2003 - Witnness 2003, a comprehensive review by Brian Kelly of the 2 days of what transpired to be the last ever Witnness festival (in 2004 it was rebranded as Oxegen when Heineken stepped into the sponsor shoes).