eoghan
Busy Member
Posts:253
 | | 15 Feb 2005 9:36 PM |
| | I've just pulbished the lowest scoring review yet to make it on CLUAS. Yes, check out Jules review of Erin McKeown's recent gig in The Village. He scores her 1 out of 10. Check the review out here:
http://www.cluas.com/music/gigs/erin_mckeown.htm
Anybody at the gig? If so do you agree with Jules' take on her performance?
eoghan | | | |
|
Gar
CLUAS Forum Junkie
Posts:1676
| | 15 Feb 2005 9:54 PM |
| | A very funny review, had me laughing out loud. What was the one for in the rating though? | | | |
|
Rev Jules
Insanely Busy Member
Posts:1110
| | 15 Feb 2005 11:06 PM |
| quote:
Originally posted by Gar
What was the one for in the rating though?
Tuning her guitar on stage without too much hassle. | | | |
|
Wicker
Busy Member
Posts:186
| | 16 Feb 2005 8:19 AM |
| "...I have never heard a guitar made to sound like a baking tray dropped repeatedly on a stone floor before. As for the voice, it takes a certain kind of talent to sing off key consistently. Even the Muppets on ‘You’re a Star’ manage to hit the odd right note occasionally........"
Hilarious review  | | | |
|
klootfan
Insanely Busy Member
Posts:860
| | 16 Feb 2005 8:49 AM |
| | wow..thats some review...was she really that bad.
Were you dragged along so or were you really expecting a good night ? | | | |
|
Bez Light year
Getting Into It Member
Posts:28
| | 16 Feb 2005 2:52 PM |
| Originally posted by Wicker
"...I have never heard a guitar made to sound like a baking tray dropped repeatedly on a stone floor before".
Thats a talent, i want to hear more people who can make a guitar sound like that.
Its easy to make a guitar sound like a guitar sure even the muppets on your a star can do that. | | | |
|
bonzo
Very Busy Member
Posts:385
| | 16 Feb 2005 3:37 PM |
| | Sounds like a truly awful gig. Funny review. loving the 1/10. | | | |
|
Archie
Very Busy Member
Posts:439
| | 16 Feb 2005 6:14 PM |
| | Great review, but it kind of had the wrong effect on me: now I want to go see her play. | | | |
|
Binokular
CLUAS Forum Junkie
Posts:1600
| | 16 Feb 2005 8:01 PM |
| quote:
Originally posted by klootfan
wow..thats some review...was she really that bad.
Were you dragged along so or were you really expecting a good night ?
I gotta ask the same question, how come you went to the gig when we already know you aren't exactly fond of the artist in question? Get dragged along or just decide you didn't have enough irritation in your life?  | | | |
|
Unicron
CLUAS Forum Junkie
Posts:1687
| | 16 Feb 2005 8:50 PM |
| | 2 small problms with the review:
1. I actually think "queen of quiet" is a decent little tune.
2. HOW DARE YOU BESMIRCH ZIG AND ZAG, you'll pay Jackson, one day you'll pay.
Otherwise I really enjoyed it, could feel the hate. On the basis of point 1 I went to see her play the acoustic tent at Glasto 2003, I left after about 4 minutes. | | | |
|
Made Of Stone
Getting Into It Member
Posts:22
| | 17 Feb 2005 9:35 AM |
| | Man that review is hilarious | | | |
|
John Doe
Very Busy Member
Posts:328
| | 18 Feb 2005 11:17 AM |
| | That's a comic masterpiece in my estimation. | | | |
|
mickod
Starting Member
Posts:4
| | 01 Mar 2005 10:18 AM |
| | its a bit harsh considering the love and adulation moany bastards like damo rice gets.
erin is inoffensive and actually quite a decent guitarist (for a girl :o) but tis true, it's all me me me. i woke up and did this, i felt like that, i'm so happy, i'm so sad. erin has a few catchy dittys. she is no dylan. shes pop dressed in indiekid gear.
i enjoy her as background music and sunday afternoon hangover music.
| | | |
|